Journal of American History · 2013 · 12 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesBusiness EconomicsEconomicsEconomic HistoryMicroeconomicsPublic EconomicsConsumer CultureConsumer SocietyConsumer TheoryHistory Of ConsumptionConsumer Goods ProductionConsumption In The HomeHome Consumption
Carolyn M. Goldstein argues that home economists contributed to the formation of modern consumer culture by playing “a mediating role in the development and marketing of consumer goods” (p. 9). To support her thesis Goldstein offers numerous examples of government agencies, corporations, and utility companies enlisting the services of home economists who advocated for what Goldstein terms “rational consumption” (p. 60). The greatest strength of Creating Consumers is Goldstein's extensive primary-source evidence documenting the sheer number of home economists involved in corporate and government endeavors from 1900 through the 1950s: in the U.S. Food Administration during World War I, the Bureau of Home Economics (created in 1923), and the power industry from 1920 to 1940, for example. Goldstein also breaks new ground by demonstrating the complex and contradictory ways home economists viewed their work as corporate employees. By examining documents from the American Home Economics Association, she uncovers a lively intraorganizational debate that took place in the 1930s about the role of home economists in business, as increasing numbers of their members took positions with companies such as Kraft Foods and Procter & Gamble. Even while home economists worked to overcome gender barriers in the interwar workplace, they debated and disagreed about their function in the business world: Were they consumer advocates, marketers, or both?