Southern Economic Journal · 1994 · 43 citations · 7 references
Public HealthLiteratureAssessment FairnessManuscript StudiesMeta-analysisBiasBias ControlPeer ReviewPublication BiasSelection BiasSystematic ReviewBlindingDouble-blind ReviewEditorial Peer ReviewPeer Review In JournalismPublication Selection BiasSingle-blind ReviewType I ErrorType Ii Error
Although we find Blank's results compelling, it is difficult to draw solid conclusions from them. Perhaps this is what Ashenfelter meant when he referred to the ambiguous findings regarding the nature of any biases. The issue of scientific concern vis-a-vis type of review process employed by journal editors is the severity of type-I and type-II errors. Do editors employing a single-blind review process systematically publish more papers that have little or no impact on the profession and/or fail to publish more truly good papers than do editors of double-blind journals? Blank's findings do not provide certain relevant information with respect to the type-I/typeII error problem that arguably plagues single-blind reviewing but not double-blind reviewing.
7
Let's Take the Con Out of Econometrics
Edward E. Leamer · American Economic Review · 1982 · 2.3K citations