Does government funding depoliticize non-governmental organizations? Examining evidence from Europe

Elizabeth A. Bloodgood, Joannie Tremblay‐Boire

European Political Science Review · 2016 · 90 citations · 62 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Prior research indicates that government funding can both encourage political advocacy and discipline NGOs through threat of withdrawal, while radical NGOs may avoid such funding to preserve legitimacy. The study tests whether government funding dampens NGO lobbying by exploring two theoretical mechanisms. Analysis of EU Transparency Register data shows a statistically significant negative relationship between government funding share and lobbying expenditure, indicating that such funding dampens NGOs’ political activity.

Abstract

Prior work suggests that government funding can encourage non-governmental organizations (NGOs) to engage in political advocacy and public policy. We challenge this finding and examine two theoretical explanations for the dampening effect of government funding on NGO lobbying. First, donors are known to discipline NGO activity via an implicit or explicit threat to withdraw funding should the organization become too radical or political. Second, NGOs with more radical political agendas are less willing to seek or accept government funding for fear this will limit or delegitimize their activities. Using data from the European Union’s Transparency Register, we find that the share of government funding in NGO budgets is negatively associated with lobbying expenditure. This effect is statistically significant and substantial, which provides a reason for concern about NGO resource dependence. Even when governments are motivated by honorable intentions, their financial assistance has the (unintended) effect of dampening NGOs’ political activity.

References

62