The Relationship between Board-Level Technology Committees and Reported Security Breaches

Julia L. Higgs, Robert Pinsker, Thomas Smith, George R. Young

Journal of Information Systems · 2016 · 186 citations · 35 references

Concepts

TL;DR

High‑profile data breaches have prompted corporate boards to prioritize IT risk oversight and face growing disclosure decisions. The study examines whether establishing a board‑level technology committee signals a firm’s capacity to detect and respond to security breaches. The authors use a returns analysis to show that technology committees reduce the negative abnormal stock returns from external breaches. Firms with technology committees are more likely to report breaches—especially when committees are young and breaches are externally sourced—but as committees mature, breach likelihood declines, and the committees also mitigate negative abnormal returns, contributing to IT governance, signaling, and disclosure literature.

Abstract

ABSTRACT After several high-profile data security breaches (e.g., Target Corporation, Michaels Stores, Inc., The Home Depot), corporate boards are prioritizing the oversight of Information Technology (IT) risk. Firms are also increasingly faced with disclosure decisions regarding IT security breaches. This study proposes that firms can use the creation of a board-level technology committee as part of the firm's information technology governance (ITG) to signal the firm's ability to detect and respond to security breaches. Using reported security breaches during the time period 2005–2014, results indicate that firms with technology committees are more likely to have reported breaches in a given year than are firms without the committee. Further analysis suggests that this positive association is driven by relatively young technology committees and external source breaches. Specifically, as a technology committee becomes more established, its firm is not as likely to be breached. To obtain further evidence on the perceived value of a technology committee, this study uses a returns analysis and finds that the presence of a technology committee mitigates the negative abnormal stock returns arising from external breaches. Findings add to the evolving ITG literature, as well to the signaling theory and disclosure literatures.

References

35