Using history in the creation of organizational identity

Mike Zundel, Robin Holt, Andrew Popp

Management & Organizational History · 2016 · 79 citations · 100 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Organizations frequently use history to establish or maintain identity, yet little research reviews the benefits and drawbacks of this practice or its impact on how history is appreciated and the insights gained. The study aims to distinguish two uses of history in organizational identity: committing external audiences and fostering inward commitment. The authors use speech act theory to develop a taxonomy of historical uses and outline the opportunities and challenges of shaping identity through historical narratives. They find that engaging with history demands sensitivity to contemporary conventions and that recognizing asynchronous historical contexts yields new insights beyond current instrumental concerns.

Abstract

Organizations frequently draw on history as a resource, for instance when attempting to establish or maintain identity claims. However, little has been done to review the advantages and problems of such use of history and it is not clear how using history impacts on the appreciation of history itself and, ultimately, on the insights that may be gained when engaging with the past. To begin to address these questions we distinguish two related uses of history as a resource for organizational identity: as a means of committing external audiences and, as a way of finding inward commitment. We theorize these two uses by drawing on speech act theory to develop a taxonomy of uses of history and to elaborate the opportunities and challenges that come when historical narratives are fashioned in the service of identity. We conclude with a further insight gained from speech act theory that suggests an engagement with history that requires sensitivity to prevailing conventions at the moment of these historical acts. We argue that appreciation of asynchronous historical conditions and contexts affords new insights through the difference these pose to current and instrumental concerns that otherwise guide the fashioning and interpretation of historical 'facts.'

References

100