Invalidation of the Intracavity Optogalvanic Method for Radiocarbon Detection

Cantwell G. Carson, M. Stute, Yinghuang Ji, Roseline Polle, Arthur Reboul, Klaus S. Lackner

Radiocarbon · 2016 · 11 citations · 23 references

Concepts

Abstract

Abstract The intracavity optogalvanic spectroscopy (ICOGS) method has been reported to quantify radiocarbon at subambient levels (<1 part per trillion). ICOGS uses a gas sample that is ionized in a low-pressure glow discharge located inside a 14 CO 2 laser cavity to detect changes in the discharge current under periodic modulation of the laser power to determine the 14 CO 2 concentration of the sample. When claims of detection thresholds below ambient levels were not verified by other researchers, we constructed a theoretical analysis to resolve differences between these conflicting reports and built and tested an ICOGS system to establish a lower limit of detection. Using a linear absorbance model of the background contribution of 12 CO 2 and data from the HITRAN database, we estimate that the limit of detection (3 σ x ) is close to 1.5×10 4 Modern. By measuring a 1.5×10 4 Modern enriched CO 2 sample in a cavity modulation ICOGS system without a clear signal, we conclude that for this system the limit of detection for ICOGS must be above 1.5×10 4 . The implications for previous ICOGS reports are discussed.

References

23