Journal of Cognition and Development · 2015 · 38 citations · 26 references
HumanitiesEarly Childhood EducationChild DevelopmentCreativityPaintingAbstract ArtExpression In ArtExpressionist PaintingVisual ArtsAbstract Form
While it is sometimes claimed that abstract art requires little skill and is indistinguishable from the scribbles of young children, recent research has shown that even adults with no training in art can distinguish works by abstract expressionists from superficially similar works by children and even elephants, monkeys, and apes (Hawley-Dolan & Winner, 2011). We presented 4-7- and 8-10-year-olds with 18 paired images, one in each pair by an abstract expressionist and the other by a child or animal, and asked which they preferred and which was better. Each participant viewed the first third of the pairs unlabeled and the rest either with correct or reversed labels (artist, and child, monkey, or elephant). Three unexpected findings emerged. First, even 4-7-year-olds can distinguish works by artists from superficially similar works by children and animals when there are no labels to guide them. Second, children’s aesthetic responses are not aligned with those of adults: children often chose works labeled child or animal whether or not this label was correct, and sometimes justified their choices by crediting the effort the child or animal had made (e.g., “it’s really good for an elephant”). Finally, children, like adults, were more likely to select artist images when making quality judgments than when indicating preferences, showing that they make a distinction between intuitive preference responses and more cognitive quality judgment responses. That even preschoolers can discriminate between works by abstract expressionists and works by children and animals underscores what is wrong with the oft-heard statement, “My kid could have done that.”
26
Feeling and thinking: Preferences need no inferences.
Robert B. Zajonc · American Psychologist · 1980 · 7.8K citations · Full text
A model of aesthetic appreciation and aesthetic judgments
Helmut Leder, Benno Belke, Andries Oeberst et al. · British Journal of Psychology · 2004 · 1.9K citations
Humanities, Fine Arts, Aesthetics +13
The arts and the creation of mind
Choice Reviews Online · 2003 · 990 citations
Social Sciences, Performing Arts, Cognitive Neuroscience +12
Richard G. Coss, Rhoda Kellogg · Leonardo · 1971 · 455 citations
Justin Kruger, Derrick Wirtz, Leaf Van Boven et al. · Journal of Experimental Social Psychology · 2003 · 408 citations