Fair Use and the Visual Arts, or Please Leave Some Room for Robin Hood

Stephen E. Weil

The Knowledge Bank (The Ohio State University) · 2001 · 20 citations · 1 references

Full text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

This paper rests on two foundations.One is the conception of fair use that federal Judge Pierre N. Levall has so eloquently articulated over recent years, i.e., that fair use is not an exception to copyright's overall objective but, rather, wholly consistent with that objective. 2If copyright's initial purpose was, as Leval has argued, to be an incentive that would stimulate progress in the arts for the intellectual enrichment of the public, then what is basically required in order to determine whether any particular use is or is not a fair one is a two-pronged inquiry.First, is the use consistent with copyright's underlying purpose of stimulating further productive thought and public instruction? 3Second, if so does it then do so without unduly dampening copyright's incentive for creativity?The other foundation upon which this paper rests is the proposition that the realms of the verbal and the visual are so fundamentally different that the rules developed to govern fair use in the one realm-language-based rules developed primarily in the context of the printed word-are not necessarily the most productive rules by which to govern fair use in the other.What will be argued here is that the objective of copyright could better be achieved if the visual arts had a distinct and separate fair use regime of their own.In considering the outlines of such a regime, regard must be given not only to the ways in which the visual arts, taken as a whole, differ from their creative counterparts in other realms and most especially from the domain of the printed word, but also to the ways in which the various genres within the visual arts differ from one another.Four such differences are considered below.

References

1