The Perils of Laura Watson Benedict: A Forgotten Pioneer in Anthropology

Jay H. Bernstein

CUNY Academic Works (City University of New York) · 1985 · 27 citations · 0 references

Full text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

The acquisition of the Philippine Islands in 1898 as the United States' most important overseas possession signalled a period of heightened interest in those islands. In the first decade of the twentieth century, American scientists, educators, politicians, military leaders, businessmen, and clergymen looked with interest at the Philippines and produced a substantial literature on their lands, resources, peoples, and history, and on the problems of their administration. In 1904 the American public was treated to a major exhibit on the Philippines at the Louisiana Purchase Centennial Exposition, a World's Fair held at St. Louis. The spectacle of wild peoples from the Philippines aroused the nation's curiosity and imagination (Rydell 1980). The exhibit ? a stunning success, later imitated at other expositions ? made unmistakable statements about the white Americans' superiority over the little brown men and underlined a perceived moral obligation to rule them and bring them up to their own exemplary standard. Anthropological theory provided a scientific justification for American supremacy over the Philippine tribes. Anthropological work in the Philippines began promptly with the establishment of the Bureau of Non-Christian Tribes of the Islands as a branch of the Department of the Interior in 1901. The Bureau brought the ethnological display to St. Louis and promoted and published the research of anthropologists trained in America. The Bureau, later reorganized as the Philippine Ethnological Survey, functioned during a time of significant transition in anthropology. The character of anthropology changed as the discipline dissociated itself from the evolutionism inherent in the St. Louis Exposition and became firmly grounded in university programs, especially at the graduate level. By 1916, when Laura Watson Benedict published her remarkable Study of Bagobo Ceremonial, Magic and Myth, the Ethnological Survey had been discontinued and the wave of American enthusiasm for the Philippines had largely dissipated. When Benedict's study had been first conceived, that enthusiasm was at its height. It is in this context of changing priorities in American society that Benedict's career must be considered. Her