Experimental Evaluation of the Performance of Available Backover Prevention Technologies

Elizabeth N. Mazzae, W. Riley Garrott

2006 · 16 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

In response to Section 10304 of the Safe, Accountable, Flexible, Efficient Transportation Equity Act: A Legacy for Users (SAFETEA-LU), the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) conducted a study of methods of reducing the incidence of injury, death, and property damage caused by collisions of backing passenger vehicles. Available backover avoidance technologies were identified and eleven were chosen for examination. Eight sensor-based systems were examined: four original equipment systems and four aftermarket systems. One of each of the original equipment and aftermarket sensor systems included rear video as part of the system. One original equipment rearview camera only system was examined. Two mirror systems were examined: one original equipment system and one aftermarket system. NHTSA conducted testing to measure a variety of aspects of object detection performance of sensor-based systems with the ability to detect objects at short range. Measurements included static field of view, static field of view repeatability, and dynamic detection range for a variety of test objects. The ability of systems to detect an adult male walking in various directions with respect to the rear of the vehicle was assessed. Sensor system detection performance was also assessed in a series of static and dynamic tests conducted using 1-year-old and 3-year-old children. Response time of sensor-based systems was also measured for a standard object. An examination of rear video and auxiliary mirror systems was also conducted which involved measurement of field of view and displayed image quality. Sensor-based systems generally exhibited poor ability to detect pedestrians, particularly children, located behind the vehicle. Systems’ detection performance for children was inconsistent, unreliable, and in nearly all cases quite limited in range. Based on calculations of the distance required to stop from a particular vehicle speed, detection ranges exhibited by the systems were not sufficient to prevent many collisions with pedestrians or other objects. The rearview video systems examined had the ability to show pedestrians or obstacles behind the vehicle and provided a clear image of the area behind the vehicle in daylight and indoor lighted conditions. While the auxiliary mirror systems tested also displayed any rear obstacles present, their fields of view covered a smaller area behind the vehicle than did the video systems tested, and the displayed images were subject to distortion caused by mirror convexity and other factors (e.g., window tinting) making rear obstacles more difficult to recognize in the mirror. In order for visual backing systems to prevent crashes, drivers must look at the video display or auxiliary mirror, perceive the pedestrian or obstacle, and respond correctly. In order to fully estimate the benefits obtainable from implementation of backover avoidance systems, further research is needed to determine how backing crashes with pedestrians actually occur (e.g., location of the children, vehicle speeds) and how drivers will use the systems and the rate of their compliance with system warnings.