PubMed · 2006 · 26 citations · 14 references
LawCriminal LawCriminal ProcedureForensic PsychiatryForensic PsychologyCompetence To Stand TrialCompetency AssessmentCompetency EvaluationEvidence-based AssessmentTrial ProcedureAssessmentsClinical Utility AssessmentCompetence To Stand Trial EvaluationCompetency To Stand Trial EvaluationCompetency To Stand Trial ReportsDefendant Competency EvaluationsMacarthur Competence Assessment ToolPractical Utility
Several instruments have been developed to assess defendants' competence to stand trial (CST). These instruments have become increasingly sophisticated mainstays of CST evaluation research. Less is known, however, about their clinical utility. Continuous quality-improvement (CQI) efforts within forensic practice are one means of helping ascertain the effectiveness and efficiency of the use of these measures, especially in public sector settings. In this article, the authors describe a CQI project examining the use of the MacArthur Competence Assessment Tool-Criminal Adjudication (MacCAT-CA) on an inpatient forensic evaluation service. Results of a small, local CQI project cannot be generalized to all settings. However, from this CQI experience, the authors found the MacCAT-CA to be advantageous in assessing CST in certain defendants. Given some limitations of its practical utility, including its use with defendants putting forth poor effort, those with significant cognitive impairments, and those from various cultural backgrounds, the authors did not find that it would be an efficient practice to utilize the instrument in all CST assessments within a busy, public sector, inpatient forensic evaluation service. Having the instrument available for use as an adjunct to a clinical interview in particular cases may offer the most advantage. In addition, it is a useful tool for educating trainees about complex CST domains. This case-based CQI project reveals some basic strengths and weaknesses of the instrument and offers direction for further exploration in a systematic research study.
14
Crossing the Quality Chasm: A New Health System for the 21st Century
BMJ · 2001 · 10.8K citations
Adjudicative competence and youthful offenders.
Richard J. Bonnie, Thomas Grisso · 2000 · 156 citations
Law, Criminal Law, Criminology +14
Competency for Trial: A Screening Instrument
Paul D. Lipsitt, David Lelos, Aidan McGarry · American Journal of Psychiatry · 1971 · 146 citations