Left Libertarianism and the Ownership of Natural Resources

Hillel Steiner

2009 · 54 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

In this paper I develop a natural resource based account of just redistribution. First, I show how rights to natural resources derive their singular importance from conditions rights have to meet. Then, I turn to the problem of self-ownership and defend a natural resources based solution against the view that we should state by moral fiat that everyone just is a self- owner. After discussing why my solution is a unifying handle on diverse intuitions we have about differential abilities and the fair distribution of their results, I conclude that our just rights to natural resources entitle each of us to an unconditional initial capital grant (not as a basic positive right). In the end I criticise Rawls' classification of abilities and disabilities as products of circumstance and list some pre-theoretical intuitions my account succeeds in sustaining.