Annales Geophysicae · 2014 · 53 citations · 39 references
Natural SciencesEarth SciencesMeteorologyAtmospheric ScienceClimate ScienceClimatologyClimate ChangeClimate ModelingGlobal WarmingRadiation BalanceRadiative ForcingSurface Radiation BudgetClimate Change Effects On Surface RadiationCloud Cover Effects On Surface RadiationCloud Radiative Effects In Climate ModelsCloud Radiative Forcing ParameterizationCloud-radiation InteractionsDifference MapsLongwave Radiative FluxesShortwave Cloud Radiative Effects
Abstract. In this paper, radiative fluxes for 10 years from 11 models participating in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 5 (CMIP5) and from CERES satellite observations have been analyzed and compared. Under present-day conditions, the majority of the investigated CMIP5 models show a tendency towards a too-negative global mean net cloud radiative forcing (NetCRF) as compared to CERES. A separate inspection of the long-wave and shortwave contribution (LWCRF and SWCRF) as well as cloud cover points to different shortcomings in different models. Models with a similar NetCRF still differ in their SWCRF and LWCRF and/or cloud cover. Zonal means mostly show excessive SWCRF (too much cooling) in the tropics between 20° S and 20° N and in the midlatitudes between 40 to 60° S. Most of the models show a too-small/too-weak LWCRF (too little warming) in the subtropics (20 to 40° S and N). Difference maps between CERES and the models identify the tropical Pacific Ocean as an area of major discrepancies in both SWCRF and LWCRF. The summer hemisphere is found to pose a bigger challenge for the SWCRF than the winter hemisphere. The results suggest error compensation to occur between LWCRF and SWCRF, but also when taking zonal and/or annual means. Uncertainties in the cloud radiative forcing are thus still present in current models used in CMIP5.
39
Cloud-Radiative Forcing and Climate: Results from the Earth Radiation Budget Experiment
V. Ramanathan, R. D. Cess, Edwin F. Harrison et al. · Science · 1989 · 1.9K citations
Toward Optimal Closure of the Earth's Top-of-Atmosphere Radiation Budget
Norman G. Loeb, Bruce A. Wielicki, David R. Doelling et al. · Journal of Climate · 2008 · 1K citations · Full text
ENSO representation in climate models: from CMIP3 to CMIP5
Hugo Bellenger, Éric Guilyardi, Julie Leloup et al. · Climate Dynamics · 2013 · 916 citations