Consuming narratives: the political ecology of ‘alternative’ consumption

Raymond L. Bryant, Michael K. Goodman

Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers · 2004 · 330 citations · 122 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study investigates how tropical conservation and social justice themes shape representational practices that underpin alternative consumption in the North. The authors use commodity culture to analyze two consumption practices: Edenic myth‑making linking tropical deforestation concerns to conservation‑oriented North lifestyles, and fair trade linking social injustice concerns to solidarity‑seeking radical lifestyles. The study finds that these commodity cultures align with opposing red–green positions but are weakened by an uncritical reliance on consumption as the main mode of social and political action.

Abstract

This paper examines how political ecology themes of tropical conservation and social justice become representational practices underpinning ‘alternative’ consumption in the North. The notion of commodity culture is adopted to understand the ambiguous rationalities and ethical assumptions of two sets of consumption practices. The first case considers Edenic myth‐making used to assimilate concerns over tropical deforestation in the South to consumption‐intensive if conservation‐minded lifestyles in the North. The second case looks at fair trade and how concern about social injustice and unfair labour practices in the South is harnessed to solidarity‐seeking consumption constitutive of ‘radical’ lifestyles. The paper suggests these contrasting commodity cultures broadly conform to divergent positions in red–green debates. It argues that both are weakened as a form of social and political ‘caring at a distance’ due to an uncritical acceptance of consumption as the primary basis of action.

References

122