Scenario-based reservoir modelling: the need for more determinism and less anchoring

Mark Bentley, Simon Smith

Geological Society London Special Publications · 2008 · 47 citations · 16 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Scenario‑based reservoir modelling prioritises deterministic control of model design, contrasting with probabilistic approaches that generate many stochastic realizations and with traditional rationalist single best‑guess models. The study aims to develop improved methods for multiple‑history matching and to link deterministic scenario outcomes to probabilistic reporting. Experimental design methods provide a solution, offering a simple, practical workflow for linking deterministic scenarios to probabilistic outputs. Scenario modelling eliminates the need to anchor on a base‑case, yields wider uncertainty ranges, preserves explicit parameter‑outcome dependencies, and has been successfully applied to both new and mature fields, highlighting the non‑uniqueness of modelling.

Abstract

Abstract The scenario-based reservoir modelling method places a strong emphasis on the deterministic control of the model design, contrasting with strongly probabilistic approaches in which effort is focused on the ‘richness’ of a geostatistical algorithm to derive multiple stochastic realizations. Scenario-based approaches also differ from traditional ‘rationalist’ modelling, which often involves the construction of only a single, best-guess or base-case model. The advantage of scenario modelling is that there is no requirement to anchor on a preferred, base-case model, and it is argued here that selection of a base case is detrimental to achieving appropriately wide uncertainty ranges. Multiple-deterministic scenario modelling also carries the advantage of maintaining explicit dependency between model parameters and the ultimate model outcome, such as a development plan. The approach has been applied widely to new fields, where multiple deterministic reservoir simulations of a suite of static models can be easily handled. The approach has also been extended to mature fields, in which practical approaches to multiple-history matching are required. Mature field scenario modelling, in particular, illustrates the weaknesses of base-case modelling, and delivers a strong statement on the non-uniqueness of modelling in general. Current issues are the need to develop better methodologies for multiple-history matching, and for linking discrete, deterministic, scenario-based outcomes to probabilistic reporting. Experimental design methods offer a solution to the latter issue, and a simple, practical workflow for its application is described.

References

16