Journal of Behavioral Decision Making · 1990 · 857 citations · 18 references
Veterinary MedicinePreventive MedicineImmunizationRisk PerceptionVaccinologyBiasDecision Under AmbiguityVaccinationVaccine EffectivenessOmission BiasParental Vaccine Decision-makingVaccination Decision-making
Subjects are reluctant to vaccinate a child when the vaccine can cause death, even if that risk is lower than the disease risk, an omission‑bias effect that persists even when knowledge of a risk group is unavailable and aligns with ambiguity interpretations. The reluctance is amplified when a risk group exists, even though membership cannot be tested, but this amplification is not due to assuming the child is in the risk group, and overall risk‑group status does not affect reluctance.
Abstract Subjects are reluctant to vaccinate a (hypothetical) child when the vaccination itself can cause death, even when this is much less likely than death from the disease prevented. This effect is even greater when there is a ‘risk group’ for death (with its overall probability held constant), even though the test for membership in the risk group is unavailable. This effect cannot be explained in terms of a tendency to assume that the child is in the risk group. A risk group for death from the disease has no effect on reluctance to vaccinate. The reluctance is an example of omission bias (Spranca, Minsk & Baron, in press), an overgeneralization of a distinction between commissions and omissions to a case in which it is irrelevant. Likewise, it would ordinarily be prudent to find out whether a child is in a risk group before acting, but in this case it is impossible, so knowledge of the existence of the risk group is irrelevant. The risk‐group effect is consistent with Frisch & Baron's (1988) interpretation of ambiguity.
18
Risk, Ambiguity, and the Savage Axioms
Daniel Ellsberg · The Quarterly Journal of Economics · 1961 · 7.9K citations
Business, Mathematics, Philosophy +12
Daniel Kahneman, Amos Tversky · American Psychologist · 1984 · 6.5K citations
Status quo bias in decision making
William Samuelson, Richard Zeckhauser · Journal of Risk and Uncertainty · 1988 · 5.9K citations
The Tanner Lectures on Human Values
Christine Pierce · Idealistic Studies · 1990 · 2.3K citations
Humanities, Psychology, Ethics +4