When does a physical system compute?

Unknown author(s)

Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences · 2014 · 118 citations · 25 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Computing is a high‑level process of a physical system, and while recent interest in quantum and biological computers has highlighted this physical basis, there is no consensus on how to determine whether a given physical system is acting as a computer, leading to confusion over novel computational devices. The paper introduces a formal framework to determine whether a physical system is performing a computation. The framework specifies conditions for computing, illustrates them across non‑standard scenarios, and defines a computational entity to identify computing in systems lacking a human user. The authors show that the abstract computational level interacts with the physical device level, enabling precise descriptions of experiments, technology, computation, and simulation, and conclude that physical computing is the use of a physical system to predict the outcome of an abstract evolution.

Abstract

Computing is a high-level process of a physical system. Recent interest in non-standard computing systems, including quantum and biological computers, has brought this physical basis of computing to the forefront. There has been, however, no consensus on how to tell if a given physical system is acting as a computer or not; leading to confusion over novel computational devices, and even claims that every physical event is a computation. In this paper, we introduce a formal framework that can be used to determine whether a physical system is performing a computation. We demonstrate how the abstract computational level interacts with the physical device level, in comparison with the use of mathematical models in experimental science. This powerful formulation allows a precise description of experiments, technology, computation and simulation, giving our central conclusion: physical computing is the use of a physical system to predict the outcome of an abstract evolution. We give conditions for computing, illustrated using a range of non-standard computing scenarios. The framework also covers broader computing contexts, where there is no obvious human computer user. We introduce the notion of a 'computational entity', and its critical role in defining when computing is taking place in physical systems.

References

25