An Even Sterner Review: Introducing Relative Prices into the Discounting Debate

Thomas Sterner, U. Martin Persson

Review of Environmental Economics and Policy · 2008 · 477 citations · 30 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The Stern Review estimated climate damages to be an order of magnitude higher than earlier estimates, shaping policy debate, but has faced criticism that its conclusions rely on a too‑low discount rate. The authors argue that the Stern Review’s conclusions can be justified without a low discount rate. They contend that underestimating nonmarket damages and rising relative prices from future scarcities—modeled via a modified DICE framework—should be incorporated into climate cost estimates. Incorporating relative prices raises estimated climate damages and can offset discounting effects, producing abatement levels comparable to those derived from a low discount rate.

Abstract

By estimating that the cost of unmitigated climate damages is an order of magnitude higher than most earlier estimates, the Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change has had a major influence on the policy discussion on climate change. Not surprisingly, severe criticism has been levied against the report, especially by those who claim that the Stern Review's results hinge mainly on a discount rate that is too low. While we have no strong objections to the discounting assumptions adopted in the Stern Review, our main point in this article is that the conclusions reached in the Stern Review can be justified without using a low discount rate. We argue that nonmarket damages from climate change are probably underestimated and that future scarcities caused by the changing composition of the economy and climate change should lead to rising relative prices for certain goods and services. This will raise the estimated damage of climate change and modify as well as counteract the effect of discounting. We illustrate this effect using a slightly modified version of Nordhaus's DICE model and show that taking relative prices into account can have as large an effect on economically warranted abatement levels as a low discount rate.

References

30