Political Psychology · 2013 · 441 citations · 45 references
Social SciencesPolitical ScienceSocial PsychologyGenderPublic OpinionStereotypingGender BiasGender DifferencesGender StereotypesStereotype ContentStereotypesVoting BehaviorElectoral Gender BiasGender Stereotype ContentGender Stereotype MeasurementProfessional StereotypesSelection Of Comparison GroupsStereotype Content AssessmentWomen CandidatesWomen In Electoral Politics
Voter gender stereotypes are cited as a key reason for the underrepresentation of women in elected office, yet prior research assumes female candidates are stereotyped like women (e.g., as compassionate). The study challenges the assumption that female politicians are stereotyped like women, proposing they form a distinct subtype, and discusses implications for future stereotype measurement. The authors compare female politician stereotypes with those of politicians, male politicians, and female professionals. The analysis reveals that female politicians lack the warm, empathetic traits attributed to women, appear to lose on male stereotypical qualities, and overall have nebulous, unclear stereotypes compared to other groups.
One explanation for the dearth of women in elected office is that voters stereotype candidates based on their gender. Research in this vein often assumes that female candidates will be stereotyped similarly to women (e.g., as compassionate) and measures stereotypes as such. We question this assumption, proposing instead that female politicians constitute a subtype—a new stereotypical category with its own qualities—of the broader group of women. We compare the content of female politician stereotypes to other relevant comparison groups including politicians, male politicians, and female professionals. Using a classic methodology to determine stereotype content ( K atz & B raly, 1933), we find that female politicians do not share the qualities that are ascribed to women (e.g., warm, empathetic). Our results show that female politicians seem to be “losing” on male stereotypical qualities while also not having any advantage on qualities typical of women. The content of female politician stereotypes is nebulous and lacks clarity in comparison to all other groups examined. We discuss implications for the future measurement of politician stereotypes.
45
The Handbook of Social Psychology
Arthur E. Gravatt, Gardner Lindzey, F. Aronson · The Family Coordinator · 1969 · 12.7K citations
Elizabeth G. Menaghan · Contemporary Sociology A Journal of Reviews · 2004 · 2.8K citations
Through the labyrinth: the truth about how women become leaders
Choice Reviews Online · 2008 · 1.9K citations