Leadership and Organizing: Sensemaking in Action

Annie Pye

Leadership · 2005 · 255 citations · 29 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The pursuit of a “Holy Grail” in leadership research suggests that efforts may be misdirected, and that leadership, as a form of social influence, is difficult to distinguish from other relational influences yet its future‑oriented emphasis aligns it with organizing. The article challenges prevailing assumptions about leadership by empirically illustrating a chief executive’s attempt to lead global change in a large organization. The authors use a case analysis to reframe leadership as a sense‑making process. The study concludes that framing leadership as sensemaking clarifies daily leadership practices, though it does not supplant leadership as a distinct focus.

Abstract

This article aims to challenge some of the assumptions which we make in our understanding of leadership, through empirical illustration from a large organization where a chief executive endeavours to ‘lead’ global change. The continuing search for the Holy Grail, which seems to characterize interest in leadership, implies that research efforts are perhaps being directed at ‘solving the wrong problem’. Leadership as a form of social influence is hard to distinguish from many other influences in relationships between people yet, it is argued, its emphasis on moving towards future action encourages a conception not dissimilar to organizing. The case analysis developed in this article goes on to reframe leadership as an example of sensemaking. It concludes that while sensemaking will never replace leadership as a focus or topic of interest, to understand leadership as a sensemaking process helps illustrate more clearly what happens in the daily doing of leading.

References

29