Charge‐Transport Anisotropy in a Uniaxially Aligned Diketopyrrolopyrrole‐Based Copolymer

Sam Schott, Eliot Gann, Lars Thomsen, Seok‐Heon Jung, Jin‐Kyun Lee, Christopher R. McNeill, Henning Sirringhaus

Advanced Materials · 2015 · 169 citations · 56 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Aligned films of a semiconducting DPP-based copolymer exhibit highly anisotropic charge transport with a band-like temperature dependence along the alignment direction and hole mobilities of up to 6.7 cm2 V−1 s−1. X-ray diffraction measurements reveal an exceptional degree of in-plane alignment, high crystallinity, and a dominant face-on orientation of the polymer backbones. The surprising charge-transport properties are interpreted in a tie-chain model consistent with anisotropic activation energies. Solution processable semiconducting polymers have recently experienced a boost in performance with charge carrier mobilities in field-effect transistors (FETs) exceeding 1 cm2 V−1 s−1 in several families of donor–acceptor (D-A) copolymers.1 These polymers have become viable candidates not only for applications in flexible displays and electronics, but also for other devices that rely on efficient charge transport such as organic solar cells and light emitting diodes. Some of the highest performing donor–acceptor polymers known today are based on diketopyrrolopyrrole (DPP) electron accepting units with reported FET mobilities exceeding 1 cm2 V−1 s−1 for both hole-transport and electron-transport.2-6 D-A copolymers exhibit a relatively complex backbone structure comprised of alternating electron deficient and electron rich units. They frequently defy a trend established with semicrystalline polymers such as poly(3-hexylthiophene-2,5-diyl) (P3HT) and poly(2,5-bis(3-alkylthiophen-2-yl)thieno(3,2-b)thiophene) (pBTTT)7, 8 of high carrier mobilities being correlated with a high degree of crystallinity. Many high mobility D-A copolymers show less crystalline, in some cases near amorphous structures. Important factors for the excellent charge transport properties of these materials are a close π–π stacking distance around 3.7 Å,9-11 a high molecular weight ensuring a network of tie chains that connect the residual crystalline domains12 and a low degree of energetic disorder due to a robust planar backbone conformation without backbone torsion.13 However, the predominant face-on stacking observed in some high mobility systems9, 14, 15 and first reports of a band-like temperature dependence of the field effect mobility above 200 K16, 17 are examples of the surprising physical properties of these polymers that remain to be fully understood. An attractive method to improve charge transport in liquid crystalline (LC) polymers is via the introduction of long-range order by macroscopic in-plane alignment of polymer backbones.18 In-plane alignment not only enhances mobilities along the preferential backbone direction but also provides a unique opportunity to study the interplay of film morphology and charge transport. The resulting anisotropy of charge transport has played an important role in demonstrating the influence of relative orientations between crystalline grains,19 discriminating between interchain and intrachain transport when polymer chains provide sufficient connectivity between crystallites12, 20 and probing the influence of anisotropic molecular packing in molecular single crystals.21 Here we study the charge transport properties of uniaxially aligned films of poly[[2,5-bis(2-octadecyl)-2,3,5,6-tetrahydro-3,6-diketopyrrolo[3,4-c]pyrrole-1,4-diyl]-alt-(2-octylnonyl)-2,1,3-benzotriazole] (DPP-BTz), a recently developed ambipolar DPP-benzotriazole copolymer with mobilities in spin-coated, top gate FETs of around 2.5 cm2 V−1 s−1 and a semicrystalline microstructure with pronounced face-on preferential orientation of polymer chains with respect to the substrate.22 The chemical structure of DPP-BTz is shown in Figure 1a. The combination of a dithienyl-DPP unit with weak electron-deficient moieties such as benzothiadiazole (BT) or benzobisthiadiazole (BBT) has proven to yield high performing ambipolar polymers.14 With DPP-BTz, we followed this design route by using benzotriazole (BTz) as comonomer. Even though challenging to synthesize, this molecular design allows for an additional alkyl side-chain to be attached to the BTz comonomer and permits the tuning of morphology and charge transport through side chain engineering. As discussed by Gruber et al., attaching linear side-chains to the DPP unit and a branched side-chain to the BTz unit both significantly changes the conformation of polymer chains and improves charge carrier mobilities.22 There are several established methods to induce alignment in conjugated polymer films, based on either the application of macroscopic forces or the use of prestructured template layers. Among the templating methods, two prominent techniques are spin-coating on top of a rubbed polyimide layer23, 24 or drop-casting on a nano-grooved SiO2 surface.25, 26 Methods based on the application of macroscopic forces include dip-coating27-29 and zone-casting,30-33 which have been shown to induce high degrees of alignment for small molecules, rubbing the polymer film itself34, 35 and solution-shearing.36-39 While techniques employing only low shearing forces proved unsuccessful in aligning DPP-BTz, we present here a newly developed shearing process based on a flexible, solution resistant lamella made of perfluoropolyether (PFPE). This delivered smooth and uniform films with high uniaxial polymer chain alignment that allowed us to study the charge transport anisotropy in this polymer with very high carrier mobilities up to 6.7 cm2 V−1 s−1 along the chain direction. DPP-BTz was deposited from chlorobenzene (CB) solutions (10 mg mL–1) on top of glass substrates either through a standard spin-coating process or by shearing with a flexible lamella made from photocured PFPE with the substrate fixed on top of a heated sample stage. Only 7 μL of solution are required to cover a 15 mm × 15 mm substrate by solution shearing compared to 30–50 μL that are necessary to insure uniform coverage in a standard spin-coated process. A schematic of the setup is depicted in Figure 1b and further details can be found in Section A of the Supporting Information. The main parameters determining film uniformity and the degree of alignment were shearing speed, substrate temperature and the choice of solvent. DPP-BTz shows characteristics of a lyotropic LC polymer with the size of crystallites in a cast film strongly depending on the amount of preaggregation induced by a solvent.40 This becomes evident when comparing films spin-coated from different solvents beneath a cross-polarizing optical microscope (Figure 1c): using chloroform, a solvent known for suppressing the formation of aggregates,40, 41 no crystalline structure is discernible while films spun from CB exhibit dark and bright patches that correspond to crystallites that are either tilted (bright) or parallel to one of the polarizers (dark). For the shear alignment process we therefore used CB as solvent. The solvent evaporation rate is set by the stage temperature (fixed at 60 °C) and the boiling point of CB at 131 °C and the degree of alignment is then determined by adjusting the shearing speed. The degree of alignment was quantified by the dichroic ratio in polarized UV–vis absorption spectroscopy where and denote the peak absorbance at either the 0–0 or 0–1 vibrational peak. Note that the optical transition dipole moment (TDM) is likely to have a nonzero component perpendicular to the polymer backbone42 which implies that R only provides a lower bound for the degree of alignment, i.e., R would remain finite even in case of perfectly aligned polymer chains. We suspect that the high degree of orientation of polymer chains is facilitated by highly planar backbones. Hydrogen–oxygen interactions between DPP and its adjacent thiophene units are known to increase backbone planarity with density functional theory predicting only small dihedral angles between DPP and its neighbours.46 As Kim et al. proposed for sulfur–fluorine interactions between adjacent units, such intra­molecular interactions promoting chain planarity combined with the use of bulky side chains promote lyotropic LC behavior in conjugated polymers.18 The decrease of dichroic ratios with higher shearing speeds initially seems counter-intuitive since a larger flow-field should result in better alignment. This decrease of R most likely stems from the position of film formation relative to the shearing lamella: the solvent evaporation rate is fixed by boiling point and stage temperature so that the point of film formation/drying moves away from the lamella with increasing speeds. This gives chains more time to reorganize again in solution after experiencing the shear force and results in weaker alignment. At speeds below 100 μm s−1 however, a significant part of the solvent already evaporates before the shearing process, resulting in nonuniform films or hampering film formation. This manifests itself in smaller dichroic ratios due to nonuniform coverage of samples and higher error bars from higher signal-to-noise ratios. Surface profiles from atomic force microscopy (AFM) given in Figure S1, Supporting Information, accordingly show a larger surface roughness. By optimizing the evaporation rate through the choice of solvent and substrate temperature it may be possible to improve the deposition speed of the process for practical applications. Polarized absorption is an easily accessible and powerful technique for probing the electronic structure and degree of alignment. But it allows only indirect access to the orientation and stacking of polymer backbones. GIWAXS directly probes stacking distances and the morphology via the diffraction of X-rays by crystalline regions of the film.47 Measurements were performed on a spin-coated reference film and a film sheared at 102 μm s−1, both on top of glass substrates. Details of the setup and measurement conditions are given in Section C of the Supporting Information. 2D scattering patterns (Figure 3) show a very pronounced face-on orientation of backbones with five visible orders of alkyl stacking peaks in the in-plane direction and a sharp π-stacking peak in the out-of-plane direction. The close π–π stacking distance of 0.38 ± 0.01 nm and the alkyl stacking of 3.0 ± 0.1 nm (extracted from the peak spacing Qhkl via ) is comparable to values from other high mobility D-A copolymers.1 The coherence length τ of alkyl spacing was estimated from the radial full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the first alkyl stacking peak via Scherrer's equation with QFWHM in nm−1.47 The many orders of alkyl-stacking peaks along the Qxy axis and the large alkyl-stacking coherence length of 31 ± 1 nm confirm an exceptional degree of crystallinity and face-on anisotropy for this DPP copolymer. An overview over extracted spacing and coherence lengths is given in Table 2. Within the accuracy of our measurements, they remain the same for the sheared and spin-coated samples. Aligned films are therefore likely to exhibit the same chain conformation and packing as spin-coated films with an absence of lattice strain or other nonequilibrium effects that were observed for zone-casted TIPS-pentacene.38 The most distinct feature of the 2D scattering patterns is the disappearance of almost all alkyl stacking peaks apart from the first order at Qxy ≈ 0.2 Å−1 in the measurement perpendicular to the alignment direction. This is expected for a pronounced uniaxial, face-on chain orientation in which X-rays impinging at grazing incidence normal to the chain alignment direction are not scattered by the periodicity associated with side chain lamellae. An additional peak at Qxy ≈ 1.15 Å−1 (spacing of 0.55 nm) increases in intensity with the perpendicular measurement. It can most likely be assigned to the backbone repeat unit and thus confirms the uniaxial chain-alignment. The nomenclature was chosen to emphasize that the distribution is in principle proportional to the scattering intensity after careful rescaling to account for changes in scattering geometries. The resulting value span of SGIWAXS = 0.91–0.95 demonstrates an exceptional orientation of crystallites. The slightly lower order parameter estimated from polarized absorption probably stems from including amorphous and crystalline regions as well as the effect of off-axis transition dipoles perpendicular to the polymer chain axis. The degree of alignment is, to the best of our knowledge, among the highest achieved for semiconducting polymers. Near edge X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy probes the angle dependent absorption of linearly polarized X-rays into the C1s-π* resonance.49, 50 Unlike GIWAXS, it is sensitive to both crystalline and amorphous regions and allows for the extraction of the average orientation of polymer backbones due to the orientation of C1s-π* TDMs normal to the (Figure X-rays are polarized linearly in the of incidence and by over different angles or angles of the X-ray it is possible to the degree of uniaxial in-plane alignment and the average of conjugated with respect to the substrate the degree of in-plane alignment, we the X-ray fixed at normal incidence = and over angles the around the surface normal (Figure The degree of alignment is again quantified in of the 2D order parameter which to the between maximum and and that are achieved perpendicular and parallel to the alignment A of can be found in Section of the Supporting Information. DPP-BTz was deposited conditions as for GIWAXS but on top of substrates to to the different behavior of on film morphology be with some when comparing FET performance with polarized The intensity in electron yield peaks at with the X-ray parallel to the C1s-π* transition dipole moment and perpendicular to the direction of alignment and its at parallel to alignment (Figure both and and is sensitive to the top nm of the film where the electron is sufficient to the The resulting order parameter of confirms a significant degree of in-plane alignment, smaller achieved values for = and = This in-plane order compared to optical and GIWAXS a degree of order at the or that samples on order compared to samples on yield measurements were to a dichroic angle a distinct in morphology the film surface in both sheared and spin-coated The top 1 nm surface accessible in electron yield is most likely in alkyl side-chains with almost (Figure Supporting an on the sample surface should be for charge transport by the from induced FET performance increase when from = to = even though the higher in (Figure sensitive to the top and increase in sensitive yield the angle dependence of the intensity to of the Supporting allows the extraction of backbone angles as and for the surface and fully face-on This to average angles of and for the surface and Note that even though an average angle can be its value gives only into the distribution of orientations around this This dominant face-on with a of backbones the surface DPP-BTz among the most face-on semiconducting polymer reported so and values for one of the most face-on with between and angles are the same for spin-coated and aligned films, again that we not the microstructure but only the The in surface with a weaker alignment of polymer chains at the film At this it is the distinct surface morphology the deposition process or is by a lower glass transition temperature at the film surface surface value of can be up to °C lower the the same measurements on films to access the morphology of the should the or of glass transition it should be that the of TDMs to the intensity when probing in-plane alignment at normal incidence increases for backbone and for fully face-on backbones Figure The 2D order parameter extracted from is more sensitive to chains with backbones with face-on backbones and may therefore be a less of chain alignment in our face-on films optical absorption or The above shearing process was used to FETs with aligned polymer DPP-BTz was deposited from a CB solution (10 mg on top of substrates with angles from to relative to shearing direction and a length of = 20 and gate the samples were at °C for 1 a and a nm of was spin-coated on top as a gate FETs were with shearing speeds from 102 to μm s−1. films from lower shearing speeds were and to transistors and were therefore from these The in-plane alignment results in anisotropic charge transport with mobilities when transport is along the preferential direction of polymer chains and mobilities lower the spin-coated average for devices in which the direction is perpendicular to the alignment direction The average values of and for different shearing speeds are given in Figure mobility are lower the dichroic ratios extracted from absorption with a peak in mobility anisotropy at temperature for the 102 μm s−1 sample of = ± large is to the of two values with error from the distribution of mobility values extracted from different Even though the alignment is for low shearing samples exhibit lower mobilities the maximum values achieved at 131 μm s−1, of in the polymer films and a resulting At 131 μm s−1, where film and alignment are a maximum mobility of = 6.7 cm2 V−1 s−1 was achieved and characteristics in Figure Unlike several other reports of mobilities exceeding cm2 V−1 mobilities extracted for DPP-BTz were over a gate of 20 and up to a high gate of = the of mobility extraction to to only lower i.e., in of the in the characteristics we these high mobilities as robust The anisotropy of charge transport can be by being along the polymer the length along a chain is smaller nm) the interchain the even for transport parallel to the direction of chain alignment. However, a smaller of transport interchain to the when along the preferential chain direction. that distances are smaller the average distance along the backbone between it has been estimated from a model that the ratio between mobilities should be of the same order of as the dichroic ratio from polarized The that this ratio is a smaller for the sheared FETs be by weaker alignment at the in the This is consistent with the lower 2D order for the top nm in viable be that charge transport may be by and regions between crystallites while absorption are less sensitive to in the charge transport parallel and perpendicular to polymer we FET measurements at from to on both spin-coated and sheared FETs μm The temperature dependence of mobilities from the sheared and spin-coated samples (Figure shows several such as different activation for sheared peak in mobility exceeding a of at and most a over to a band-like temperature dependence of the mobility above both for spin-coated samples and for devices with transport along the shearing direction. and an temperature dependence is observed for all transport as expected for For this dependence up to and shows an activation of = ± extracted from with the and temperature This value is higher activation reported for other high mobility polymers with the but this be by disorder at the While the spin-coated a activation transport parallel to the alignment direction has two distinct regions with different At low from to is of the same size as the spin-coated and perpendicular But from to a significantly higher activation of = ± is exceeding values of for high mobility polymers benzothiadiazole or The most feature of the transport properties is the band-like temperature dependence of observed above for the sample in which charge transport is along the chain alignment direction. We this temperature dependence with characteristics from different samples and only between and up of FETs be a possible error even at temperature that would itself in activation but would not a decrease of mobilities with higher the weak at the of characteristics (Figure Supporting we only small effects and significant changes with temperature or FET direction. It is important to emphasize that in our measurements not only the extracted mobility but also the itself from to (Figure Supporting which demonstrates that in this temperature charge transport improves with lower and the observed band-like transport characteristics are not an from the mobility extraction our knowledge, are only two reports of band-like transport in semiconducting polymers at this both in D-A The first from et the band-like temperature dependence in DPP copolymer to into transport above a mobility edge and that this can be by disorder with However, they large between from near mobilities between and to transport up to which a consistent of et both band-like temperature dependence and a effect in aligned films of the copolymer They factors of at and close to above of at lower but only transport parallel to the alignment direction and above They not the between morphology and charge transport but the that they polymer films to band-like transport mobilities compared to spin-coated samples. results that along the polymer chain direction a band-like transport can be at high this transport is no but is by of the molecular or backbone Within the model developed by et al., amorphous regions that semicrystalline are by a larger and charge They are by tie chains that connect crystallites and become accessible at higher energies. case of uniaxial alignment, these tie chains would result in a between the direction of alignment, tie chains can be of chains from crystallites for transport perpendicular to the direction of chain alignment tie chains adjacent crystallites have to and thus exhibit in This would that for transport along the chain alignment direction less energetic disorder in the amorphous regions between crystallites. For transport perpendicular to the alignment the degree of energetic disorder experienced when these regions is likely to be charge transport to between in a density of with larger energetic which efficient transport along tie chains and which at higher in the become accessible for transport along the direction of chain alignment at high This is also consistent with the increase in parallel mobilities between and The above are even more when the face-on orientation of DPP-BTz with side chains in-plane between polymer chains. the degree of face-on alignment is not as high on the surface as in the this shows that the over more one π-stacking so that interchain transport as as in A has been proposed for a and copolymer with face-on where the induced transition to stacking effect on charge study demonstrates the alignment, and electronic of a liquid crystalline DPP-based by attaching linear side-chains at the DPP unit and a branched at the BTz comonomer. With a solution shearing process, we are to induce a high degree of in-plane anisotropy with in-plane order parameters from = in UV–vis absorption to = 0.91–0.95 for X-ray diffraction without lattice strain or unit The anisotropy is by a charge transport anisotropy with a between mobilities parallel and perpendicular to alignment at The anisotropy in mobility compared to anisotropy in the film can be to a morphology at the film surface which the FET by near edge X-ray absorption we are to maximum values of = 6.7 cm2 V−1 s−1 at significantly higher mobilities in spin-coated devices in one of the extracted mobility values reported for a polymer these films we have been to a band-like temperature dependence of the mobility in devices in which transport is along the polymer chain alignment direction. This band-like transport along the polymer in which transport becomes by is an important route for further the performance of polymer but to be in more The of the is at they be to transport along the polymer backbone but also be to lattice of the relative of adjacent polymer chains the for charge carrier between to is observed in high mobility molecular The from the and through a from the and This was performed in part at the and at the and of the for The were in on after As a to our and this provides by the materials are and may be for but are not or from should be to the The is not for the or of by the should be to the for the

References

56