Entrepreneurship in Russia and China: The Impact of Formal Institutional Voids

Sheila M. Puffer, Daniel McCarthy, Max Boisot

Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice · 2009 · 867 citations · 84 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Transition economies often lack robust formal institutions, creating unstable environments that entrepreneurs must navigate with greater uncertainty and risk than in developed economies. The study investigates how formal and informal institutions shape entrepreneurship in Russia and China, highlighting differences from developed economies. The authors analyze private property, trust, and blat/guanxi to assess their influence on entrepreneurial behavior in Russia and China. The authors find that entrepreneurs in Russia and China do not fully shift toward formal institutions but instead create unique balances between formal and informal institutions, offering implications for theory and practice.

Abstract

Transition economies are often characterized by underdeveloped formal institutions, often resulting in an unstable environment and creating a void usually filled by informal ones. Entrepreneurs in transition environments thus face more uncertainty and risk than those in more developed economies. This article examines the relationship of institutions and entrepreneurship in Russia and China in the context of institutional theory by analyzing private property as a formal institution, as well as trust and blat/ guanxi as informal institutions. This article thus contributes to the literature on entrepreneurship and institutional theory by focusing on these topics in transition economies, and by emphasizing how their relationship differs from that in developed economies. We conclude that full convergence toward entrepreneurs‘ reliance on formal institutions may not readily occur in countries like Russia and China due to the embeddedness of informal institutions. Instead, such countries and their entrepreneurs may develop unique balances between informal and formal institutions that better fit their circumstances. Implications for the theory and practice of entrepreneurship in such environments are also offered.

References

84