Identity Management Strategies Utilized by Lesbian and Gay Employees

Scott B. Button

Group & Organization Management · 2004 · 145 citations · 29 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Gay and lesbian employees are often presumed to choose between passing as heterosexual or openly identifying, yet prior qualitative work indicates the decision is more nuanced. The study sought to quantitatively examine identity‑management strategies among gay and lesbian employees. Confirmatory factor analyses were employed to identify the factor model that best explains patterns of behavior in organizational settings. The results showed that employees may counterfeit a false heterosexual identity, avoid discussing sexuality, or integrate their gay or lesbian identity into work, with similar patterns for both genders and evidence that strategies can be combined, underscoring their importance for individuals and organizations.

Abstract

Although it is commonly assumed that gay and lesbian employees face a dichotomous choice between passing as a heterosexual and openly identifying oneself as a sexual minority member, past qualitative research has suggested that the decision is more complex. A set of confirmatory factor analyses was conducted to examine this issue quantitatively and identify the factor model that best explains the patterns of behavior associated with identity management in organizational settings. The results revealed that gay and lesbian employees may counterfeit a false heterosexual identity, avoid the issue of sexuality altogether, or integrate a gay or lesbian identity into the work context. The factor pattern was the same for lesbians and gay males. In addition, the results suggest that these strategies may be used in combination. The importance of identity management strategies for the individual and the organization are discussed and suggestions for future research are provided.

References

29