European Journal of Psychological Assessment · 2007 · 44 citations · 21 references
Social SciencesPsychiatryPsychologyClinical PsychologyDiagnostic AssessmentPsychiatric AssessmentClinical Decision-makingDiagnostic ErrorDiagnostic EvaluationDiagnostic Test EvaluationJudgment AssessmentPsychological AssessmentClinician JudgmentComparative Diagnostic AccuracyDiagnostic Accuracy StudiesDiagnostic ExpertiseEmpirical EvaluationExpert Novice Differences
Most comparative studies of performance in psychodiagnostic classification contrast novices with very experienced clinicians, and do not include a group with an intermediate level of experience. We describe an empirical study involving 41 clinicians with three levels of experience. We asked novices, intermediates, and very experienced psychodiagnosticians to give the diagnostic (DSM) classification for 10 written cases. We found an intermediate effect in diagnosticians' decision time and correctness: Intermediates performed worse and faster than both novices and very experienced clinicians. In line with most other studies, we found that experienced diagnosticians were not significantly more accurate than novices.
21
The empirical case for two systems of reasoning.
Steven A. Sloman · Psychological Bulletin · 1996 · 3.7K citations
Choice Reviews Online · 1997 · 1.1K citations
The Routines of Decision Making
Murray Sinclair · Ergonomics · 2008 · 334 citations
Management, Behavioral Sciences, Organizational Behavior +12