Intercultural Pragmatics · 2014 · 14 citations · 0 references
Language StudiesPolitical CommunicationPolitical ScienceDiscourse AnalysisPolitical RhetoricPragmaticsArgumentationCampaign SpeechPolitical DiscourseRhetorical AnalysisRhetorical TheoryCampaign DebatesDiachronic Discourse AnalysisElection Campaign DiscourseElection DebatesElection RhetoricEvidence Use In DebatesMidterm ElectionsPolitical Rhetoric Analysis
In politics, one area where both incumbents and challengers can be seen exhibiting similar verbal behavior is during debates. In their attempts to depict an opponent as unqualified for the job, politicians must respond to claims they make against their opponents by providing evidence through the means of first- or secondhand knowledge about the claim; the encoding of this evidence and the degree to which they distance themselves from that knowledge is known as evidentiality. This paper explores evidentiality as exhibited by politicians in the 2010 US Midterm Congressional Elections debates. Starting with Chafe's (1986) work on evidential analysis, the features investigated are observed through the lens of critical discourse analysis using the Multilayered Model of Context (Berlin 2007, 2011). Evidential markers (i.e., evidentials) were coded for type and analyzed in their pragmatic functions. Findings suggest that politicians, as a group, tend to use those forms of evidentials that attenuate claims less frequently while they tend to use those forms that boost claims more frequently. Furthermore, face-to-face debates inhibit the use of more reliable evidential encoding as politicians being verbally attacked are available to counter opponents' claims and the attackers are called on to respond to their accusations.