Changing the geography of opportunity by expanding residential choice: Lessons from the Gautreaux program

James E. Rosenbaum

Housing Policy Debate · 1995 · 618 citations · 29 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The concept of geography of opportunity posits that residential location shapes individual prospects, and the study examines how attrition may influence observed outcomes and evaluates the program’s strengths and pitfalls. The study examines the Gautreaux residential integration program, which randomly assigns low‑income black families to either middle‑income white suburbs or low‑income predominantly black urban areas. The program’s design uses random assignment to compare outcomes between suburban and urban movers. Suburban movers show higher employment and better educational outcomes for youth, and, if not in college, are more likely to secure well‑paid jobs, while youth interactions with peers are similar across groups but suburban movers interact more with white peers and slightly less with black peers.

Abstract

Abstract The concept of “geography of opportunity” suggests that where individuals live affects their opportunities. While multivariate analyses cannot control completely for individual self‐selection to neighborhoods, this article examines a residential integration program—the Gautreaux program—in which low‐income blacks are randomly assigned to middle‐income white suburbs or low‐income mostly black urban areas. Compared with urban movers, adult suburban movers experience higher employment but no different wages or hours worked, and suburban mover youth do better on several educational measures and, if not in college, are more likely to have jobs with good pay and benefits. The two groups of youth are equally likely to interact with peers, but suburban movers are much more likely to interact with whites and only slightly less likely to interact with blacks. The article considers how attrition might affect the observations and speculates about the program's strengths and pitfalls.

References

29