Randomization in clinical trials of titrated therapies: Unintended consequences of using fixed treatment protocols*

Abstract

In TRICC and ARMA, randomization to fixed treatment regimens disrupted preexisting relationships between illness severity and therapy level. This created noncomparable subgroups in both study arms that received care different and opposite from titrated care, that is, practice misalignments. These subgroups reduced the interpretability and safety of each trial. Characterizing current practice, incorporating current practice controls, and using alternative trial designs to minimize practice misalignments should improve trial safety and interpretability.