Self-Generated Versus Other-Generated Statements and Impressions in Computer-Mediated Communication

Joseph B. Walther, Brandon Van Der Heide, Lauren M. Hamel, Hillary C. Shulman

Communication Research · 2009 · 463 citations · 54 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The warranting principle states that impression formation in online communication relies more on information that targets cannot control than on self‑descriptions. Two experiments using mock‑up Facebook profiles presented self‑generated and other‑generated clues to test perceptions of extraversion (N = 115) and physical attractiveness (N = 125). The results confirmed warranting, yet also revealed that negativity and additivity explanations were relevant, and that friends’ comments consistently outweighed self‑comments, underscoring warranting theory and its implications for boundary‑setting research and the impact of social comments on new information forms.

Abstract

The warranting principle pertains to impression formation in Internet communication. It posits that perceivers' judgments about a target rely more heavily on information which the targets themselves cannot manipulate than on self-descriptions. Two experiments employed mock-up profiles resembling the Internet site, Facebook, to display self-generated clues and to display other-generated clues about a Facebook user. The first experiment ( N = 115) tested perceptions of extraversion. Although warranting was supported, rival explanations (negativity and additivity) also pertained. The second experiment ( N = 125) tested perceptions of physical attractiveness. Friends' comments overrode self-comments, supporting warranting theory exclusively. Implications concern boundary-setting research for warranting, and potential effects of social comments on a variety of new information forms.

References

54