World Economy · 2010 · 61 citations · 76 references
BusinessBusiness EconomicsEconomicsExport ManagementInternational EconomicsInternational TradeComparative AdvantageExport MarketingExport PromotionExport Performance DeterminantsExport Promotion MixInternational Trade FlowsMultiple-treatment ComparisonRelative Effectiveness EstimationTrade MissionsTrade Promotion EffectivenessTrade Promotion Organizations
Export promotion agencies offer a wide array of services—from counselling to trade‑mission sponsorship—but evidence on their relative effectiveness remains scarce. This paper seeks to close that gap by evaluating how bundled trade‑promotion services compare to individual components. The authors use highly disaggregated Colombian export data (2003–06) and apply multiple‑treatment matching difference‑in‑differences to assess the impact of various public programmes on firms’ export volumes and destinations. They find that programmes combining multiple services outperform their individual components, particularly on the country‑extensive margin.
Export promotion agencies provide exporters with a broad range of services, going from counselling to sponsoring their participation in international trade missions and fairs. These services may have heterogeneous effects and thus contribute differently to achieve the goals of these organisations. Empirical evidence on their relative effectiveness is rather limited. This paper aims at filling this gap in the literature. We compare the impact of different public trade promotion programmes on the extensive and intensive margin of firms' exports, both to each other and with respect to no participation in these activities, by applying multiple treatment matching difference-in-differences on highly disaggregated export data for the whole population of Colombian exporters over the period 2003–06. We find that use of programmes that combine different services is associated with better export performance than their basic individual components, primarily along the country-extensive margin.
76
Statistics and Causal Inference
Paul W. Holland · Journal of the American Statistical Association · 1986 · 5.1K citations