Numerical Sensitivity Study of Unsteady Friction in Simple Systems with External Flows

Abstract

This paper investigates the importance of unsteady friction effects when performing water hammer analyses for pipe systems with external fluxes due to demands, leaks, and other system elements. The transient energy equation for a system containing an orifice-type external flow is derived from the two-dimensional, axial momentum equation. A quasi-two-dimensional flow model is used to evaluate the relative energy contribution of total friction, unsteady friction, and the external flow, in a 1,500m pipeline, with orifice flows ranging from steady-state flows of 2–70% of the mean pipe flow, and a Reynolds number of 600,000. It is found that for initial lateral flows larger than around 30% of the mean flow, unsteady friction effects can probably be neglected, whereas for external flows smaller than this, unsteady friction should generally be considered. Overall, the relative role of unsteady friction is found to diminish as the external flux increases, implying that unsteady friction is not critical for systems with large external flows. These results imply that unsteady friction may have a significant impact on the validity of transient leak detection techniques that have been derived assuming quasi-steady friction. To demonstrate this point, an existing transient leak detection method, originally derived under quasi-steady conditions, is tested with unsteady friction included.