Importance of Input Perturbations and Stochastic Gene Expression in the Reverse Engineering of Genetic Regulatory Networks: Insights From an Identifiability Analysis of an In Silico Network

Daniel E. Zak, Gregory E. Gonye, James S. Schwaber, Francis J. Doyle

Genome Research · 2003 · 180 citations · 45 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Gene expression profiles are increasingly used to infer system‑wide cellular functions. This study examines how much information gene expression data alone can provide for reverse‑engineering regulatory networks. The authors built an in silico genetic regulatory network and performed a formal identifiability analysis that evaluated parameter estimation accuracy based on gene expression data, known transcription factor–gene relationships, input perturbations, and stochastic gene expression. The analysis showed that, besides structural knowledge, prior kinetic information—especially mRNA degradation rates—is required for identifiability, and that complex perturbations generally outperform simple ones unless stochastic noise is high, offering a framework for similar investigations.

Abstract

Gene expression profiles are an increasingly common data source that can yield insights into the functions of cells at a system-wide level. The present work considers the limitations in information content of gene expression data for reverse engineering regulatory networks. An in silico genetic regulatory network was constructed for this purpose. Using the in silico network, a formal identifiability analysis was performed that considered the accuracy with which the parameters in the network could be estimated using gene expression data and prior structural knowledge (which transcription factors regulate which genes) as a function of the input perturbation and stochastic gene expression. The analysis yielded experimentally relevant results. It was observed that, in addition to prior structural knowledge, prior knowledge of kinetic parameters, particularly mRNA degradation rate constants, was necessary for the network to be identifiable. Also, with the exception of cases where the noise due to stochastic gene expression was high, complex perturbations were more favorable for identifying the network than simple ones. Although the results may be specific to the network considered, the present study provides a framework for posing similar questions in other systems.

References

45