JNCI Journal of the National Cancer Institute · 2005 · 297 citations · 4 references
MedicineMolecular BiologyOncologyEarly DetectionMolecular DiagnosticsProteomicsCancer BiomarkersCancer ProteomicsClinical ProteomicsOvarian CancerProteomic BiomarkersProteomic ProfilingCancer Proteome ProfilingOvarian Cancer BiomarkersOvarian Cancer Early DetectionProteomic ClassificationProteomic Data AnalysisProteomic PhenotypingProteomic SignaturesTumor Proteomics
Proteomic profiling of serum initially appeared to be dramatically effective for diagnosis of early-stage ovarian cancer, but these results have proven difficult to reproduce. A recent publication reported good classification in one dataset using results from training on a much earlier dataset, but the authors have since reported that they did not perform the analysis as described. We examined the reproducibility of the proteomic patterns across datasets in more detail. Our analysis reveals that the pattern that enabled successful classification is biologically implausible and that the method, properly applied, does not classify the data accurately. We show that the method used in previously published studies does not establish reproducibility and performs no better than chance for classifying the second dataset, in part because the second dataset is easy to classify correctly. We conclude that the reproducibility of the proteomic profiling approach has yet to be established.
4
Use of proteomic patterns in serum to identify ovarian cancer
Emanuel F. Petricoin, Ali M. Ardekani, Ben A. Hitt et al. · The Lancet · 2002 · 3.3K citations
Medicine, Gynecology, Oncology +17
Mark A. Rogers, Paul A. Clarke, Jason Noble et al. · PubMed · 2003 · 221 citations
Medicine, Biochemistry, Oncology +17
Detection of cancer-specific markers amid massive mass spectral data
Wei Zhu, Xuena Wang, Yeming Ma et al. · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · 2003 · 183 citations · Full text