The moving staircase – Problems of appraisal and evaluation in a turbulent environment

Barbara Farbey, Frank Land, David Targett

Information Technology and People · 1999 · 80 citations · 5 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The paper examines the challenges of assessing the benefits of IT investments amid institutional change. It calls for re‑integrating evaluation activities into their organisational context. The study uses a National Health Service case to track a project introducing benefits realisation in NHS Trusts. The case shows that personal, hands‑on attention to benefits management is crucial, and that formative evaluation is effective when contingencies are certain, whereas structural organisational changes are preferable when contingencies are uncertain.

Abstract

This paper considers the problems of evaluating the benefits of an investment in information technology and systems against a background of institutional change. It is based on a case study in the National Health Service and follows the progress of a project to introduce benefits realisation in NHS Trusts. The case illustrates the importance of personal, hands‐on attention to benefits management and calls attention to the different contingencies faced by managers in attempting to introduce evaluation or benefits realisation schemes. It concludes that, where managers face “certain” contingencies, formative evaluation will be beneficial, but where the contingencies are uncertain, structural changes in the organisation may be more effective in achieving benefits. The paper ends with a plea for evaluation activities to be re‐integrated into their organisational context.

References

5