Credible Commitment and Property Rights: Evidence from Russia

Timothy Frye

American Political Science Review · 2004 · 207 citations · 23 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Secure property rights are essential for economic development, yet they remain rare; the study investigates which factors promote them, including whether rightholders perceive private or state agents as greater threats and whether they value bureaucratic commitment or discretion. The study aims to assess the institutional, social, and political determinants of secure property rights using evidence from two original surveys of Russian company managers. The authors surveyed company managers in Russia to evaluate how perceptions of state arbitration courts and state officials influence property rights security. Managers reported that state arbitration courts were effective against other businesses but not against state officials, and those who trusted courts to constrain officials invested at higher rates, suggesting that stronger constraints on state agents can enhance property security and state capacity.

Abstract

Few dispute that secure property rights are critical to economic development. But if secure property rights are so beneficial, then why are they so rare? More precisely, what factors promote secure property rights? Do rightholders view private or state agents as a greater threat to property? Do they value bureaucratic commitment or discretion? I use evidence from two original surveys of company managers in Russia to assess the institutional, social, and political determinants of secure property rights. Most managers said that state arbitration courts did not work badly in disputes with other businesses, but few expected these courts to protect their rights in disputes with state officials. More importantly, managers who expressed confidence that state arbitration courts could constrain state officials invested at higher rates, even controlling for the perceived effectiveness of state institutions. Ironically, increasing constraints on state agents can increase the security of property and bolster state capacity. These results generate insights into debates on the role of state in the economy, the origins of secure property rights, the nature of state capacity, the importance of informal institutions, and the process of legal reform.

References

23