Defining the best quality-control systems by design and inspection

C. Martin Hinckley

Clinical Chemistry · 1997 · 53 citations · 11 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Quality‑control approaches vary in effectiveness, and laboratory nonconformities arise mainly from excessive process variation and mistakes, but statistical quality control can curb variation yet fails to detect or prevent most mistakes. The study explores 100% inspection methods essential for controlling mistakes. The authors examine 100% inspection methods, delineate how task complexity relates to nonconformity rates, and outline the cultural changes required to implement optimal quality‑control practices. The study finds that statistical quality control alone is ineffective because mistakes dominate nonconformities, whereas new source‑inspection methods detect and correct mistakes before nonconformities arise, delivering the highest quality at a fraction of the cost of traditional approaches.

Abstract

Not all of the many approaches to quality control are equally effective. Nonconformities in laboratory testing are caused basically by excessive process variation and mistakes. Statistical quality control can effectively control process variation, but it cannot detect or prevent most mistakes. Because mistakes or blunders are frequently the dominant source of nonconformities, we conclude that statistical quality control by itself is not effective. I explore the 100% inspection methods essential for controlling mistakes. Unlike the inspection techniques that Deming described as ineffective, the new "source" inspection methods can detect mistakes and enable corrections before nonconformities are generated, achieving the highest degree of quality at a fraction of the cost of traditional methods. Key relationships between task complexity and nonconformity rates are also described, along with cultural changes that are essential for implementing the best quality-control practices.

References

11