Diagnostic Cytopathology · 2008 · 15 citations · 13 references
MedicineGynecologyPathologyCytopathologyHistopathologySurgical PathologyCervical CancerCervical CytologyCervical LesionsCervical PathologyCervicovaginal CytologyGynecologic CytologyComparative Diagnostic PerformanceConventional Cervical CytologyCytological ExaminationCytology-based DiagnosisDiagnostic Performance MetricsGlandular Lesion DiagnosisInterobserver ReproducibilityPap Smear Cytology
Gynecological cytology has some inaccurate morphological categorization and poor interobserver reproducibility especially for glandular lesions. Liquid-based cytology (LBC) preparations are presumed to reduce artifacts that interfere in diagnosis performance, but its value to correctly identify glandular alterations has not been sufficiently reported. The objective of this study was to compare the diagnostic performance and interobserver agreement of LBC and conventional Pap smear to identify histologically confirmed glandular lesions according to five cytologists. Sensitivity ranged from 55.8 to 73.1% and 32.7 to 48.1% for Pap smear and LBC, respectively. Specificity ranged from 66.1 to 87.1% and 69.4 to 94.4%, respectively. In general, agreement between pairs of cytologists was poor with kappa-values around 0.45. In conclusion, relying entirely on cervical cytology to rule out glandular lesions may be risky. The use of HPV DNA test alone or combined to screening glandular lesions may contribute to minimize the limitations of both conventional and LBC preparations to diagnose glandular abnormalities.
13
Raheela Ashfaq, David Gibbons, Cindi Vela et al. · Acta Cytologica · 1999 · 130 citations
Medicine, Pathology, Cytopathology +11
The Bethesda interobserver reproducibility study (BIRST)
Mark E. Sherman, Abhijit Dasgupta, Mark Schiffman et al. · Cancer · 2006 · 86 citations
Medicine, Pathology, Cytopathology +16
Glandular cell atypia on Papanicolaou smears
Aylin Simsir, S.W. Hwang, Joan Cangiarella et al. · Cancer · 2003 · 66 citations · Full text
How predictive is a cervical smear suggesting glandular neoplasia?
Marie E. Mathers, Sarah J. Johnson, V. Wadehra · Cytopathology · 2002 · 38 citations
Medicine, Gynecology, Pathology +17