Memory conformity: Exploring misinformation effects when presented by another person

Daniel B. Wright, Gail Self, Chris Justice

British Journal of Psychology · 2000 · 326 citations · 12 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Two experiments demonstrate that post‑event information delivered by another person can alter people’s memory reports. The authors discuss parallels with eyewitness testimony in the Oklahoma bombing case and implications for police interviewing. In the first experiment participants viewed cars and later performed paired old/new recognition tests, while in the second they watched an identical crime with varying accomplice presence in pairs. The studies revealed a small but reliable memory‑conformity effect: misinformation lowered accuracy, accurate information increased it, and after discussion most pairs conformed, with confidence ratings predicting who persuaded whom.

Abstract

Two experiments demonstrate that post‐event information, when delivered by another person, can affect people's memory reports. In the first experiment participants were shown several cars, and later, in pairs, given an ‘old’/‘new’ recognition test on these cars plus several lures. There was a small but reliable effect of memory conformity. When the person was given misinformation this lowered accuracy, while presenting accurate information increased accuracy. In the second experiment participants, in pairs, viewed an identical crime except that half saw an accomplice with the thief and half did not. Initial memories were very accurate, but after discussing the crime with the other person in the pair (who saw a slightly different sequence), most pairs conformed. Confidence ratings strongly predicted which person in the pair persuaded the other. Parallels with eyewitness testimony in the Oklahoma bombing case and implications for police interviewing more generally are discussed.

References

12