The Laryngoscope · 2013 · 35 citations · 17 references
MedicineOtolaryngologySurgeryDiagnostic AssessmentOtolaryngologic SurgeryRhinologyCompetency AssessmentCompetency ValidationEndoscopic Sinus SurgeryNasal SurgerySkills AssessmentSurgery EducationAssessment Of Surgical CompetenceCompetencyCompetency-based Surgical EducationGlobal Rating ScalesMedical Student EducationSurgical EndoscopySurgical TrainingTechnical Skills Acquisition
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: To evaluate a previously validated low-cost sinus surgery task trainer as a means of acquiring basic endoscopic sinus surgery skills and as an objective structured assessment of technical skills (OSATS) to determine procedural competency. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective blinded study. METHODS: Medical students (N = 52) with no sinus surgery experience learned to perform nasal endoscopy and five specific sinus surgery tasks using the validated task trainer. Training included regimented expert instruction, peer instruction/observation, and experienced-based learning. Pre- and post-training video recordings of nasal endoscopy and five sinus surgery skills were obtained. Two blinded expert otolaryngologists compared pre- and post-training performance using a checklist and global rating scale. RESULTS: Medical student post-training performance was significantly better than pre-training performance for each checklist item and global rating scale as calculated by paired t test (P < .001). Interrater reliability and internal consistency were confirmed by Kendall's coefficient of concordance and Cronbach's α calculations, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The sinus surgery task trainer provides an effective means of teaching and evaluating nasal endoscopy and basic sinus surgery skills for novice surgeons. With repeated practice, there was significant improvement in performance. An OSATS using the sinus surgery task trainer suggests that we can effectively measure endoscopic sinus surgery ability with the potential to reliably determine competency outside the operating room.
17
Teaching Surgical Skills — Changes in the Wind
Richard K. Reznick, Helen MacRae · New England Journal of Medicine · 2006 · 1.7K citations
Medicine, Medical Education, Surgery +13
Teaching and testing technical skills
Richard K. Reznick · The American Journal of Surgery · 1993 · 549 citations
What do master surgeons think of surgical competence and revalidation?
A. Cuschieri, Nader Francis, Joy Crosby et al. · The American Journal of Surgery · 2001 · 184 citations