Europeanized Hypocrisy: Roma Inclusion and Exclusion in Central and Eastern Europe

Melanie H. Ram

CSUN ScholarWorks (California State University, Northridge) · 2014 · 37 citations · 8 references

Full text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

This article reflects on the outcome of Europeanization to date as it relates to Roma in Central and Eastern Europe, and seeks to explain the inherently contradictory policies and practices towards this population in the new EU member states today. It explores these policies and practices in five countries and argues that the EU's promotion of, and support for, improvements in the situation of Roma-alongside exclusionary practices in old EU member states and pre-existing attitudes in new members-has resulted in an incompatible mix of policies and practices that supports both inclusion and exclusion. Given this situation, continued EU pressure to improve the situation of Roma is unlikely, by itself, to bring about transformative change.Keywords: Europeanization, EU, conditionality, Central and Eastern Europe, minority rights, Roma, discrimination1. EU conditionality, Europeanization and the RomaFor more than a decade and a half, the European Union (EU) has singled out the Roma1-an ethnic minority constituting as many as ten to twelve million people across Europe-as a group facing widespread discrimination and socio-economic exclusion that prospective member states must address. Over the years, prompted in large part by membership expectations, pressure and funds from the EU and other international organizations (as well as criticism by non-governmental organizations (NGOs)), governments in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) adopted institutions, legislation and projects addressing discrimination, lack of political participation and socio-economic disparities of Roma. Thus, one might credit the EU with rather dramatic achievements in spurring these countries to improve the situation of this minority population. Yet discrimination, poverty, segregation and exclusion remain widespread problems among the Roma community, and have even increased in some cases; Roma also remain an under-represented minority in every country in which they live. This article reflects on the lasting outcomes for Roma of the EU's ongoing efforts since the 1990s to institute respect for, and protection of, ethnic minorities in CEE. It argues that the EU's promotion of, and support for, improved treatment of Roma has left these countries with an inconsistent mix of policies, practices and norms that support both inclusion and exclusion.Literature on EU conditionality and post-accession 'compliance' has identified many ways in which the EU has affected government policies, institutions, discourse and practices, as well as civil society activities regarding minorities (including Roma) in CEE, often with the help of facilitating factors or actors (see for example, Arias and Gurses, 2012; Kelley, 2003; Krizsan, 2009; Ram, 2001, 2003, 2007; Rechel, 2009a; Schwellnus, 2005; Williams, 2002). While scholars have duly acknowledged the EU's differential impact on minority rights of candidate countries and various limitations to its influence (see for example, Guglielmo, 2004; Hughes and Sasse, 2003; Johnson, 2006; Ram, 2003: 46-51; Rechel, 2008; Schimmelfennig, Engert and Knobel, 2003; Sissenich, 2007; Vermeersch, 2003), few would argue that attention to Roma and specific efforts to improve their situation in CEE have not been influenced by the EU enlargement process. Indeed, many scholars and practitioners believe that the positive steps taken to improve the situation of Roma would not have occurred without the EU's influence.As a result, real concerns have been raised about how removing EU conditionality upon accession has affected minority rights. Yet the EU still has the ability to influence policies and practices in its new member states, not only by adopting new policies applicable to all members, but also through mechanisms used before accession, including expressions of concern and expectations, monitoring of implementation of legislation, provision of funding and capacity building, and support for NGO advocacy and monitoring (Ram, 2012). …

References

8