The Media, the Campaign, and the Message

Julianne F. Flowers, Audrey A. Haynes, Michael H. Crespin

American Journal of Political Science · 2003 · 75 citations · 16 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study systematically examines how campaigns structure their messages, which messages are transmitted by the press to the voting public, and what factors influence the transmission of the campaign's message. The authors analyze 1996 Republican presidential nominee press releases during the invisible primary and the resulting newspaper stories, systematically evaluating campaign message structuring, press transmission, and influencing factors. Campaigns disseminate a variety of messages; national media favor informative messages from front‑running candidates and reject substantive ones, while state press prefers substantive messages from lower‑tier candidates, indicating that media rather than campaigns drive the emphasis on the horse race.

Abstract

This article examines the 1996 press releases issued by Republican presidential nominee candidates during the invisible primary and the subsequent stories generated by these press releases in newspapers. We systematically examine how campaigns structure their messages, which messages are transmitted by the press to the voting public, and what factors influence the transmission of the campaign's message. We find that campaign organizations disseminate a variety of messages to the media. Our analysis demonstrates that national media organizations are most receptive to informative (logistical) messages disseminated by candidates who are at the head of the field and most hostile to substantive (issue‐oriented) messages regardless of their campaign of origin. By contrast, the state press is most open to substantive messages issued by lower‐tier candidates. It appears from our results that the media, more than the campaign, bear the responsibility for the emphasis on the horse race.

References

16