Transportation Research Record Journal of the Transportation Research Board · 2000 · 38 citations · 3 references
PlanningTransportation PlanningUrban PlanningPedestrian PlanningStreet DesignTransportationCrosswalk DesignPedestrian Environment DesignPedestrian SafetyPedestrian TransportationPedestrian-oriented DesignSignage DesignCrosswalksIntersection Crossing BehaviorMarked CrosswalksPedestrian Behavior At IntersectionsPedestrian Crossing BehaviorPedestrian Safety DesignRoadside Pedestrian SafetyRoadway Infrastructure
Three types of pedestrian safety devices—overhead crosswalk signs, safety cones, and pedestrian‑activated overhead signs—were evaluated at unsignalized crosswalks, but alone they cannot guarantee motorists yield, and their effectiveness is enhanced when combined with education, enforcement, or geometric improvements. The study evaluated the effects of these three treatments on pedestrian and motorist behavior. The study observed pedestrian and motorist behavior under varying traffic conditions, measuring whether motorists yielded, whether pedestrians had to run, hesitate, or abort, and whether pedestrians crossed in the crosswalk. The cones in New York and the Seattle signs increased motorist yielding, the Tucson overhead sign also increased yielding, and both Seattle and Tucson signs reduced pedestrians having to run, hesitate, or abort, but none of the treatments affected the likelihood of crossing in the crosswalk.
Three types of devices that have been used in conjunction with marked crosswalks in an attempt to improve pedestrian safety were evaluated: an overhead crosswalk sign in Seattle, Washington; pedestrian safety cones (which read, “State Law: Yield to Pedestrians in Crosswalk in Your Half of Road”) in New York State and in Portland, Oregon; and pedestrian-activated overhead signs (which read, “Stop for Pedestrians in Crosswalk”) in Tucson, Arizona. The signs were used under varying traffic and roadway conditions. The effects of these three treatments on pedestrian and motorist behavior were evaluated. The variables of interest were whether pedestrians had the benefit of motorists yielding to them; whether pedestrians had to run, hesitate, or abort their crossing; and whether pedestrians crossed in the crosswalk. The New York cones and Seattle signs were effective in increasing the numbers of pedestrians who had the benefit of motorists yielding to them. At one location in Tucson, the overhead sign increased motorist yielding to pedestrians. The signs in Seattle and Tucson were effective in reducing the number of persons who had to run, hesitate, or abort their crossing. None of the treatments had a clear effect on whether people crossed in the crosswalk. By themselves, these devices cannot ensure that motorists will slow down and yield to pedestrians. It is essential to use these and other devices along with education and enforcement, but creation of friendlier pedestrian environments (e.g., by means of implementing geometric improvements) for the purpose of reducing vehicle speeds may be more important.
3
Ron Van Houten, Keenan Healey, J. E. Louis Malenfant et al. · Transportation Research Record Journal of the Transportation Research Board · 1998 · 19 citations
Planning, Transportation Planning, Accessibility Planning +16