OpenEdition (OpenEdition) · 2012 · 10 citations · 0 references
Open access
LawCriminal LawCriminologyDiscriminationFeminist TheorySexual OffensesDisparate ImpactGender DiscriminationInvestigation Of Sexual OffensesSentencing For Sexual OffensesSexual AssaultVictim ImpactCriminal Justice PoliticsEvidence Of Sexual AssaultHarm To VictimsRace Of VictimsSentencing Of Women OffendersSex Offender SentencingSexual Assault LawVictim Impact Evidence
This chapter interrogates whether or not the criminal justice system holds potential for fairly representing women’s experiences of harm while affirming their dignity, equality, and autonomy. Specifically, Rakhi Ruparelia questions the opportunity to present a victim impact statement (VIS) to the judge who is sentencing a sex offender. While not opposing a criminalization strategy, as do Alison Symington and Julie Desrosiers in the specific contexts discussed in their respective chapters, Rakhi expresses similar skepticism that the law permitting the filing of a VIS is actually premised on deeply conservative ideologies regarding who are real and what their proper role in the criminal justice system is. Like the Sexual Assault Evidence Kit originally touted as a positive development for women, the VIS is more likely to be used to discredit women’s claims than to validate them when it comes to sexual assault. Rakhi explores systemic racism in sentencing and argues persuasively that Aboriginal and racialized men will bear the brunt of VIS use and that Aboriginal and racialized women have little if anything to gain from the VIS. The VIS, she argues, is really about appeasing victims and maintaining the individualized focus of the criminal justice system.