Quality control study on negative gynecological cytology in Mexico

Abstract

An external evaluation of the quality of diagnosis of gynecological cytology specimens (Papanicolaou or "Pap" tests) in the Cytopathological Laboratory at the Mexico General Hospital was performed, with evaluation of 6,011 Pap tests randomly selected from 31,378 Pap studies previously reported as negative during 1988-1989. These tests were part of the early detection program for cervical cancer run by the Ministry of Health of Mexico City. A quality index for specimens was constructed based on the presence of endocervical cells, mucus, and squamous metaplastic cells. The index of false negatives for the diagnosis of cervical neoplasm in this sample which correspond to diagnostic error by the examiner was 0.18% (11). The constructed quality index revealed that 64.1% of specimens were low quality. The correlation between diagnostic error and low quality was .87. Results indicate that laboratories participating in early detection programs for cervical cancer in developing countries need to implement (1) external evaluation programs for Pap diagnosis; (2) permanent training programs in registration; and (3) monitoring procedures for collection, fixation, and transportation of cytologic materials.