The Cambridge Law Journal · 2004 · 54 citations · 1 references
LawConstitutional LawHuman Rights LawCivil RightsConstitutional TheoryHuman RightsCivil LibertiesEqual Protection ClauseEuropean LawHuman Rights ProtectionInternational Human Rights LawRights CritiqueBalancingConstitutional BalancingCritical Legal TheoryEuropean Human Rights LawHuman Rights ConstitutionalismHuman Rights TheoryLimitation Of RightsPower Balancing
At the core of contemporary political, constitutional, and legal theory, lie the questions of how “constitutional”, “fundamental”, and “human” rights are, and should be, reconciled with each other and with considerations of the wider public interest. This article considers how the debate between Habermas and Alexy about the appropriateness of “balancing” as a way of addressing these problems might apply to the adjudication of the European Court of Human Rights, and concludes that, with some modification, Alexy's model is to be preferred.
1