Journal of Abnormal Psychology · 2008 · 215 citations · 36 references
MedicineNutritional SciencesPsychiatryClinical NutritionEating DisordersHuman NutritionAdolescent Eating DisordersBinge-eating DisorderBulimia NervosaDisordered EatingEating Disorder EtiologyEating Disorders In AdolescenceAdolescent Binge-eating DisorderAdolescent Bulimia NervosaBinge Eating EpisodesBinge-eating Disorder EpidemiologyBulimia Nervosa EpidemiologyFasting BehaviorPredictive Relations
Adolescent girls with high dietary restraint scores are at higher risk for future binge eating and bulimia, yet only a minority develop pathology, implying that extreme, rare restriction may elevate risk. The study examined whether 24‑hour fasting for weight control predicts binge eating and bulimic onset better than dietary restraint scores in 496 adolescent girls over five years. They followed 496 adolescent girls for five years, assessing fasting episodes and dietary restraint scores to predict future binge eating and bulimic pathology. Only 23% of high‑restraint girls fasted, yet fasting predicted recurrent binge eating and bulimia more consistently than restraint over 1–5 years, supporting fasting as a stronger risk factor.
Although adolescent girls with elevated dietary restraint scores are at increased risk for future binge eating and bulimic pathology, they do not eat less than those with lower restraint scores. The fact that only a small proportion of individuals with elevated dietary restraint scores develop bulimic pathology suggests that some extreme but rare form of dietary restriction may increase risk for this disturbance. The authors tested the hypothesis that fasting (going without eating for 24 hr for weight control) would be a more potent predictor of binge eating and bulimic pathology onset than dietary restraint scores using data from 496 adolescent girls followed over 5 years. Results confirmed that only 23% of participants with elevated dietary restraint scores reported fasting. Furthermore, fasting generally showed stronger and more consistent predictive relations to future onset of recurrent binge eating and threshold/subthreshold bulimia nervosa over 1- to 5-year follow-up relative to dietary restraint, though the former effects were only significantly stronger than the latter for some comparisons. Results provide preliminary support for the hypothesis that fasting is a stronger risk factor for bulimic pathology than is self-reported dieting.
36
John L. Falk · Contemporary Psychology · 1973 · 2.3K citations
Dieting and binging: A causal analysis.
Janet Polivy, C. Peter Herman · American Psychologist · 1985 · 1.3K citations