A Systematic Uncertainty Analysis of an Evaluative Fate and Exposure Model

Edgar G. Hertwich, Thomas E. McKone, William S. Pease

Risk Analysis · 2000 · 98 citations · 0 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Multimedia fate and exposure models, such as CalTOX, are widely used to regulate toxic chemical releases, set cleanup standards, and evaluate life‑cycle emissions by calculating potential dose combined with toxicity to produce Human Toxicity Potential (HTP). This study evaluates the uncertainty in CalTOX’s potential dose calculation to inform the reliability of decisions based on HTP. The authors present a four‑type uncertainty framework—parameter, landscape, decision rule, and model—tested via Monte Carlo analysis, regional dose comparisons, boundary‑condition comparisons, and case studies on plant concentration formulations and wet‑deposition steady‑state assumptions. The analysis reveals that assuming steady‑state atmospheric removal underestimates potential dose for 25 % of 336 chemicals, indicating the assumption is inappropriate.

Abstract

Multimedia fate and exposure models are widely used to regulate the release of toxic chemicals, to set cleanup standards for contaminated sites, and to evaluate emissions in life‐cycle assessment. CalTOX, one of these models, is used to calculate the potential dose, an outcome that is combined with the toxicity of the chemical to determine the Human Toxicity Potential (HTP), used to aggregate and compare emissions. The comprehensive assessment of the uncertainty in the potential dose calculation in this article serves to provide the information necessary to evaluate the reliability of decisions based on the HTP. A framework for uncertainty analysis in multimedia risk assessment is proposed and evaluated with four types of uncertainty. Parameter uncertainty is assessed through Monte Carlo analysis. The variability in landscape parameters is assessed through a comparison of potential dose calculations for different regions in the United States. Decision rule uncertainty is explored through a comparison of the HTP values under open and closed system boundaries. Model uncertainty is evaluated through two case studies, one using alternative formulations for calculating the plant concentration and the other testing the steady state assumption for wet deposition. This investigation shows that steady state conditions for the removal of chemicals from the atmosphere are not appropriate and result in an underestimate of the potential dose for 25% of the 336 chemicals evaluated.