Cognitive Science · 1987 · 876 citations · 34 references
Language StudiesLinguisticsMorphologyPhilosophy Of LanguageSemanticsConceptual SemanticsLexical RelationsPart-whole RelationsRelational TermsSpatial InclusionTaxonomic Relations
Meronymic relations are distinct from other inclusion relations (spatial, class) and from semantic relations such as attribution, attachment, and ownership. The study develops a taxonomy of part‑whole (meronymic) relations to explain how English speakers use the term “part of” and related terms. The authors classify meronymic relations into six types—component‑integral, member‑collection, portion‑mass, stuff‑object, feature‑activity, and place‑area—and apply this taxonomy, along with relation‑element theory and a principle of element matching, to analyze intransitivities and inferential patterns in merological syllogisms. The study finds that intransitivities in merological syllogisms stem from equivocations among semantic relation types, and that a single principle of element matching accounts for the observed inferential phenomena.
A taxonomy of part‐whole or meronymic relations is developed to explain the ordinary English‐speaker's use of the term “part of” and its cognates. The resulting classification yields six types of meronymic relations: 1. component‐integral object (pedal‐bike), 2. member‐collection (ship‐fleet), 3. portion‐mass (slice‐pie), 4. stuff‐object (steel‐car), 5. feature‐activity (paying‐shopping), and 6. place‐area (Everglades‐Florida). Meronymic relations ore further distinguished from other inclusion relations, such as spatial inclusion, and class inclusion, and from several other semantic relations: attribution, attachment, and ownership. This taxonomy is then used to explain cases of apparent intransitivity in merological syllogisms, and standard form syllogisms whose premises express different inclusion relations. The data suggest that intransitivities arise due to equivocations between different types of semantic relations. These results are then explained by means of the relation element theory which accounts for the character and behavior of semantic relations in terms of more primitive relational elements. The inferential phenomena observed are then explained by means of a single principle of element matching.
34
Amos Tversky · Psychological Review · 1977 · 7.3K citations
Basic objects in natural categories
Eleanor Rosch, Carolyn Β. Mervis, Wayne D. Gray et al. · Cognitive Psychology · 1976 · 5.5K citations
Roland Hall, Ludwig Wittgenstein, G. E. M. Anscombe · The Philosophical Quarterly · 1967 · 4K citations