"Age Ought to Be a Fact": The Campaign against Child Labor and the Rise of the Birth Certificate

Susan J. Pearson

Journal of American History · 2015 · 18 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

In 1898, two decades after it had passed its first law restricting the employment of children, the state of Wisconsin still found it difficult to enforce its child labor laws. Although these laws used age as the basis of legal employment, children's ages were nearly impossible for officials to determine. The problem, the state's commissioner of labor explained, was twofold. First, he alleged, parents lied about children's ages. Second, this deception was made possible by Wisconsin's “notable lack of reliable or complete birth records.” Unable to rely on any official documentation of children's ages, state factory inspectors were forced to accept parental affidavits of age. And this testimony-based system gave rise to widespread duplicity. “Cases have even been met with,” the commissioner complained, “where parents … have changed the records of their [children's] ages in the family Bible and other places.” His complaints were typical: wherever states relied on parental affidavits of age, child labor reformers and state factory inspectors complained that children's ages were misrepresented, even when affidavits were notarized.1