Zoonoses and Public Health · 2013 · 10 citations · 19 references
Veterinary MedicineInfectious DiseasesVeterinary EpidemiologyImmunizationStochastic ModelingVaccinologyLivestock Infectious DiseasesVaccinationVaccine EffectivenessVaccine EfficacyVaccine-preventable DiseasesVeterinary VaccinationEscherichia ColiEscherichia Coli O157:h7 InfectionEscherichia Coli O157:h7 PreventionLivestock Disease RiskOverall Vaccine EffectivenessStochastic SimulationVaccination EfficacyVaccine Efficacy Evaluation
Pens of cattle with high Escherichia coli O157:H7 (STEC O157) prevalence at harvest may present a greater risk to food safety than pens of lower prevalence. Vaccination of live cattle against STEC O157 has been proposed as an approach to reduce STEC O157 prevalence in live cattle. Our objective was to create a stochastic simulation model to evaluate the effectiveness of pre-harvest interventions. We used the model to compare STEC O157 prevalence distributions for summer- and winter-fed cattle to summer-fed cattle immunized with a type III secreted protein (TTSP) vaccine. Model inputs were an estimate of vaccine efficacy, observed frequency distributions for number of animals within a pen, and pen-level faecal shedding prevalence for summer and winter. Uncertainty about vaccine efficacy was simulated using a log-normal distribution (mean = 58%, SE = 0.14). Model outputs were distributions of STEC O157 faecal pen prevalence of summer-fed cattle unvaccinated and vaccinated, and winter-fed cattle unvaccinated. The simulation was performed 5000 times. Summer faecal prevalence ranged from 0% to 80% (average = 30%). Thirty-six per cent of summer-fed pens had STEC O157 prevalence >40%. Winter faecal prevalence ranged from 0% to 60% (average = 10%). Seven per cent of winter-fed pens had STEC O157 prevalence >40%. Faecal prevalence for summer-fed pens vaccinated with a 58% efficacious vaccine product ranged from 0% to 52% (average = 13%). Less than one per cent of vaccinated pens had STEC O157 prevalence >40%. In this simulation, vaccination mitigated the risk of STEC O157 faecal shedding to levels comparable to winter, with the major effects being reduced average shedding prevalence, reduced variability in prevalence distribution, and a reduction in the occurrence of the highest prevalence pens. Food safety decision-makers may find this modelling approach useful for evaluating the value of pre-harvest interventions.
19
Heterogeneous shedding of <i>Escherichia coli</i> O157 in cattle and its implications for control
Louise Matthews, J. C. Low, David L. Gally et al. · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · 2006 · 262 citations · Full text
Veterinary Medicine, Infectious Disease Control, Veterinary Epidemiology +17