Self‐assessment and physician assessment of sexual maturation in Brazilian boys and girls: Concordance and reproducibility

Sandra Mahecha Matsudo, Victor Keihan Rodrigues Matsudo

American Journal of Human Biology · 1994 · 220 citations · 7 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study examined the concordance between self‑assessment and physician assessment of sexual maturity status in Brazilian children, youth, and young adults. Participants (174 females, 178 males, aged 6‑26) self‑rated their sexual maturation stage, after which a physician evaluated the same subjects, and the two sets of ratings were compared. Moderate to high concordance (60.9‑71.3%) was observed overall, with better agreement for pubic hair (69.7‑71.3%) than for breasts or genitals (≈60%), and accuracy depended more on maturation stage than age. © 1994 Wiley‑Liss, Inc.

Abstract

This study considered the concordance of self-assessment and physician assessment of sexual maturity status; breasts, and pubic hair in girls, and genitals and pubic hair in boys. The subjects were Brazilian children, youth and young adults, 174 females and 178 males, 6-26 years of age. Each subject evaluated his/her level of sexual maturation and then was examined by a physician. The sexual maturity ratings of the subjects and physicians were compared. Overall, the results showed moderate to high concordance (60.9-71.3%) for both assessments of secondary sex characteristics; better concordance was found for pubic hair (69.7-71.3%) than for the breasts or genitals (60%). Age did not appear to influence the accuracy of self-evaluation; rather, accuracy was more dependent on stage of maturation of the subject. Correlations between self- and physician assessments, and replicate self- and physician assessments were relatively high. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.

References

7